The Battery or Alternator? How to Tell Which Is Causing Your Car Not to Start

Your Car Battery Is Not Charging, but Why?

If there’s a problem with the vehicle not starting and you’re not sure if it’s the battery or alternator, our experts have tips that can help you diagnose which is the cause. Follow these steps to learn how to test an alternator and battery with a multimeter.

Fix a bad alternator yourself with quality auto parts at 1aauto.com

How to Test the Battery and the Alternator with a Multimeter

How to Test the Battery with a Multimeter

Battery terminals with corrosion
Battery terminals with corrosion

Inspect the battery terminals and battery connectors for corrosion. If corrosion is present, clean it from the terminals. Once the terminals are clean, you can test the battery for the charge to determine if the issue is resolved.

There are a few ways to test the battery. A multimeter or special tools like a battery analyzer that connects to the terminals can measure the voltage. The steps below explain how to test a car battery with a multimeter.

Battery analyzer that can test the battery voltage

Test the Battery for Charge with a Multimeter

Steps for Testing the Battery for Charge with a Multimeter

  1. Set the Meter to over 15 Volts

    Set the multimeter DC voltage above 15 volts.

  2. Measure the Battery Voltage

    Connect the multimeter leads to the negative and positive battery terminals. Read the voltage. If the voltage reads under the 12 volt range near 11 to 11.5 volts, the battery is weak.

  3. Measure the Battery Voltage with the Electrical Accessories on

    Turn on different electrical accessories like the headlights, wipers, and fan. Monitor the multimeter’s measurement. If it falls in the 10 volt range, the battery is weak.

  4. Measure the Battery Voltage with the Electrical Accessories off

    Turn off the electrical accessories and monitor the multimeter’s measurement. It should rise to the 12 volt range.

How to Test the Charge Sent to the Battery from the Alternator

Steps for checking the charge sent from the alternator to the battery

  1. Start the vehicle
  2. Turn on various electrical accessories
  3. Rev the engine to 1,500 to 2,000 RPM
  4. Measure the current with the multimeter, which should read in the 13.5 to 14.2 volt range. A higher voltage is excessive and not good for the battery.

Note: If the voltage reads too low or too high, the alternator isn’t pushing the correct amount of electrical current.

How to Test the Alternator with a Multimeter

Note: Older vehicles will have a generator and newer ones will have an alternator. They are two different systems.

Mechanic’s Tip: Not all alternators have a voltage regulator as part of their design. The alternator could be regulated by the power control module (PCM). If you disconnect the negative battery terminal and test an alternator that has a voltage regulator or one that is regulated by the PCM, you could cause detrimental damage to the charging system—likely the voltage regulator itself.

Testing the alternator with a multimeter

1. Measure the Alternator Voltage

If the car won’t start but the battery is good, the problem could be the alternator. You should test the alternator to make sure it is functioning properly. Insert the multimeter’s positive lead to the positive voltage wire connector. It is usually a bolt underneath a rubber boot. Then you can touch the multimeter’s negative lead to the ground wire terminal, which is where the ground wire connects to the alternator.

A reading in the 12 volt range is a good reading and indicates there is the same battery voltage at the alternator.

2. Start the Vehicle and Turn on the Electrical Accessories

Start the vehicle and turn on all the electrical parts to increase the load. Measure the voltage, which should read between a 13 and low 14 volt range.

If the multimeter reads for high voltage like 14.7 volts, the alternator is overcharging. If it reads for low current, it is undercharging.

3. Inspect an Undercharging Alternator

Confirm the alternator’s pulley is working, spinning, and not binding if the alternator is undercharging.

If the alternator is full of dust and build-up, the brushes inside the alternator are probably faulty and the alternator will not generate the right amount of electricity.

Voltage regulator from an alternator
Voltage regulator with diodes (black spots)

If you are able to remove the alternator and can remove the rear cover of the alternator, you can inspect the voltage regulator.

Corrosion on a voltage regulator

Check the condition of the diodes and confirm they are not corroded or falling apart.

Alternator brush in good condition with a slightly worn spring
Alternator brush in good condition with a slightly worn spring

Check inside the alternator and see if the brushes are worn. Over time, the springs can wear, leaving the brush in contact with the copper insulator and wearing it down over time.

Alternator pulley bearing
Alternator pulley bearing

Check the condition of the pulley bearing. If the pulley spins too much, is too loose, or binds, it is defective.

How to Replace a Bad Alternator or Battery Yourself

Replace a bad alternator or battery yourself with 1A Auto’s how-to videos that have step-by-step instructions for many makes and models

Shop Quality Parts Mentioned in This Article

Related Content

Summary
Battery or Alternator? - Car Won't Start - Battery Not Charging - 1A Auto
Article Name
Battery or Alternator? - Car Won't Start - Battery Not Charging - 1A Auto
Description
If there's a problem with the vehicle not starting and you're not sure if it's the battery or alternator, our experts have tips that can help you diagnose which is the cause.
Author
Publisher Name
1A Auto
Publisher Logo

One thought to “The Battery or Alternator? How to Tell Which Is Causing Your Car Not to Start”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *